The Atlantic Ocean Breaking on Our Heads: Claudia Rankine, Robert Lowell, and the Whiteness of the Lyric Subject. PMLA/Publications of the Modern Language Association of America, vol. Definitions and examples of 136 literary terms and devices. claudia rankine is oxygen to a world under water. Sometimes you sigh. Citizen: An American Lyric essays are academic essays for citation. It is agonizing to display our flayed skin to the salt of another day. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. Even though it will be obvious that the girl behind her is cheating, the protagonist obliges by leaning over, wondering all the while why her teacher hasnt noticed. What did he say? The separation of the Black and white subjects acts as a visual metaphor for the racial segregation of the Jim Crow era, as the Black and white subjects are separatednot only by the wooden frame of the image, but by the page itself. Instant PDF downloads. Read it all in one flow. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Requesting a new guide requires a free LitCharts account. Courtesy of John Lucas. On the drive back from the movie, the protagonist receives a call from her neighbor, who tells her that theres a sinister looking man walking back and forth in front of her house. Words can enter the day like "a bad egg in your mouth and puke runs down your blouse" (15). By utilizing form, visual imagery, and poetry, Rankine enables us to see the systemic oppression of Black people by the state. Chingonyi, Kayo. Trump is of course unapologetically and infamously racist against various races (and religions, women, and so on), so the woman behind Trump uses the opportunity to read this anti-racist book, knowing it will get national coverage; we see the title, we check it out: Powerful political commentary. I met Rankine in New York in mid-October while she was in town for the Poets Forum, presented by the Academy of American Poets, for which she serves as a chancellor. Its dark light dims in degrees depending on the density of clouds and you fall back into that which gets reconstructed as metaphor. The large white space on top of the photograph seems to be pushing the image down, crushing the small black space. I Am Invested in Keeping Present the Forgotten Bodies.. Believer Magazine, 28 June 2020, believermag.com/logger/2014-12-10-i-am-invested-in-keeping-present-the-forgotten/. Rankine writes: we are drowning here / still in the difficultythe water show[ed] [us] no one would come (85). This juxtaposition between black space and white space, body and no body, presence and absence, conveys the erasure of Black people on a visual level. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Requesting a new guide requires a free LitCharts account. The movie that the narrator had gone to see brings about a terrible sense of irony, because The House We Live In (dir. Best to drive through the moment instead of dwelling on it. Claudia Rankine's book Citizen: An American Lyric was a New York Times bestseller and won many awards. Her repetition of this question beckons us to ask ourselves these questions, and the way the question transitions from a focus on the lingering impact of the event (haveyou seen their faces) to a question of historicity (didyou see their faces) emphasizes the ways these black bodies disappear from life (presence) to death (absence). Some of these encounters are slights, seeming slips of . Perhaps this dissociation, seen in the literariness of Rankines poetics and use of you, speaks to the kind of erasure of self that happens when you experience racism every day. PDF downloads of all 1699 LitCharts literature guides, and of every new one we publish. When she tells him not to get all KKK on the teenagers, he says, Now there you go, trying to make it seem like the protagonist is the one who has overstepped, not him. By talking about her experiences in second-person, Rankine creates a kind of separation between herself and her experiences. A provocative meditation on race, Claudia Rankine's long-awaited follow up to her groundbreaking book Don't Let Me Be Lonely: An American Lyric. I saw the world through her eyes, a profound experience. You exhaust yourself looking into the blue light. The structure, which breaks up the poetics with white space and visual imagery, uses space and mixed media to convey these themes. Rankine does more than just allude to the erasureshe also emphasizes it through her usage of white space. Black people are facing a triple erasure: first through microaggresions and racist language that renders them second-class citizens; then through lynching and other forms of violence that murders the black body; and lastly, through forgetting. In her book-length poem "Citizen," from 2014, the writer Claudia Rankine probed some of the nuances and contradictions of being a Black American.Her focus fell on what it means to be erased . InCitizen, Rankine does more than illustrate the erasure and lynching of Black people, for the image of a deer is also used as a metaphor to symbolize the dehumanization of Black people in America. -Graham S. Would not have made it through AP Literature without the printable PDFs. In response, the protagonist turns the question back around, asking why he doesnt write about it. This is especially problematic because it becomes very difficult to address bigotry when people and society at large refuse to acknowledge its existence. Claudia Rankine zeros in on the microaggressions experienced by non-white people, particularly black females, in the United States. The decision to place Clarks image right after Rankines recount of a microaggression, where Rankine is yelled off the deer grass (Skillman 429) of a white therapist like some unwanted wild animal, shows us how white America views Black people: as pests and prey. So much racism is unconscious and springs from imagined . One example is the employer who says he had to hire "a person of color when there are so many great writers out there" (15). Rankine repeats: flashes, a siren, the stretched-out-roar (105, 106, 107) three times. Citizen: An American Lyric Quotes and Analysis "Sometimes the moon is missing and beyond the windows the low, gray ceiling seems approachable. The disembodied heads of the Black subject does not only allude to lynching and captivity, as the 16 sections of the cupboard look like 16 prison cells, but it also represents the way bodies are stacked on top of one another in slave ships (Skillman 447). Claudia Rankine, (born January 1, 1963, Kingston, Jamaica), Jamaican-born American poet, playwright, educator, and multimedia artist whose work often reflected a moral vision that deplored racism and perpetuated the call for social justice. When she objects to his use of this word, he acts like its not a big deal. Skillman, Nikki. But when the interactions are put together, the reader can understand the "headache-producing" (13) capacity of these interactions. The therapist is yelling for you to leave, and you manage to tell her that you have an appointment. Project MUSEmuse.jhu.edu/article/732928.Sdf, The Dissolving Blues of Metaphor: Rankines Reconstruction of Racism as Metaphor in Citizen: An American Lyric, www.guernicamag.com/blackness-as-the-second-person/. Her son went to another prestigious university instead. A damn hard read but a damn necessary one. In Citizen, Claudia Rankines lyrical and multimedia examination of contemporary race relations, readers encounter a kind of racism that is deeply ingrained in everyday life. Political performance art. Anyway, I read this is a single sitting in bed and recommend it to everyone. The woman grabs his arm and tells him to apologize. It's raining outside and the leaves on the trees are more vibrant because of it. The inescapability of their social condition and positioning, of their erasure and vulnerability, is also emphasized in Rankines highly stylised poem about the Jena Six (98-103). A friend called you by the name of her black housekeeper several times. I nearly always would rather spend time with a novel. When he says this, the protagonist realizes that the humorist has effectively excluded her from the rest of the audience by exclusively addressing the white people in the crowd, focusing only on their perspective while failing to recognize (or care about) how racist his remark really is. To see so many people moved and transformed by her work and her vision is something that should give us all hope. The wrong words enter your day like a bad egg in your mouth and puke runs down your blouse, a dampness drawing your stomach in toward your rib cage. A man in line refers to boisterous teenagers in the Starbucks as niggers. This consideration of numbness continues into the concluding section, entitled July 13, 2013the day Trayvon Martins killer was acquitted. Rankines small book of essays tells us the myriad ways we consistently misinterpret others motives, actions, language. The world says stop that. You'll also get updates on new titles we publish and the ability to save highlights and notes. Brilliant, deeply troubling, beautiful. It's / buried in you; it's turned your flesh into . Rankine stresses the importance of remembering because forgetting is part of the erasure. What did she just do? At one point, she attends a reading by a humorist who implies that its common for white people to laugh at racist jokes in private, adding that most people wouldnt laugh at this kind of joke if they were out in public where black people might overhear them. Instead of following the woman to ask why she did this, the protagonist took her tennis racket and went to the court. In context, the author is referring to the weight of memory, the racial insults, the slights, and the mistreatment by other players. (Rankine 59). Bella Adams(2017)Black Lives/White Backgrounds: Claudia Rankines Citizen: An American Lyricand Critical Race Theory,Comparative American Studies An International Journal,15:1-2,54-71,DOI:10.1080/14775700.2017.1406734. Yes, and leads to a narrow pathway with no forks in the road. Their impact is the result, in part, of their . Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. On campus, another woman remarks that because of affirmative action her son couldn't go to the college that the narrator and the woman's father and grandfather had attended. The work incorporates lyric essay, prose poem, verse poem, and image in its exploration of the ways in which racism can affect identity. Analysis Of Citizen By Claudia Rankine. You are in Catholic school and a girl who you can't remember is looking over your shoulder as you take a test. To demonstrate this, she turns to the career of the famous African American tennis player Serena Williams, pointing to the multiple injustices she has suffered at the hands of the predominantly white tennis community, which judges her unfairly because of her race. Whether Rankine is talking about tennis or going out to dinner, or spinning words until youre not sure which direction youre facing, there is strength, anger, and a call for white readers like myself to see whats in front of us and do better, be better. Citizen is definitely a must read for everyone, especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism all together. You are in Catholic school and a girl who you can't remember is looking over your shoulder as you take a test. Creating notes and highlights requires a free LitCharts account. From this description, it is clear that Rankine sees the I as a symbol for a human being, for she later states: the I has so much power; its insane (71). The picture is of a well-manicured suburban neighborhood with sizable houses in the background. At another event, the protagonist listens to the philosopher Judith Butler speak about why language is capable of hurting people. A nuanced reflection on race, trauma, and belonging that brings together text and image in unsettling, powerful ways. LitCharts Teacher Editions. Jenn Northington. Look at the cover. She says the things that we have all said and describes situations we have all been in. Black Blue Boy, 1997.Courtesy of Carrie Mae Weems. LitCharts Teacher Editions. The artwork which is featured on the coverDavid Hammons In the Hood depicts a black hood floating in a white space. Published in 2014, Citizen combines prose, poetry, and images to paint a provocative portrait of the African American experience and racism in the so-called "post-racial" United States. Graywolf, 169 pp., $20.00 (paper) Nick Laird. A mixed-media collection of vignettes, poems, photographs, and reproductions of various forms of visual art, Citizen floats in and out of a multiple topics and perspectives. In Claudia Rankines, Citizen: An American Lyric, she explores racism in a unique way. Between the World and Me. One World, 2015. At Like in Sections IV and III, Rankine puts special focus on the body and its potentials to be made known. In the photograph, there are no black bodies hanging, just the space where the two black bodies once were (Chan 158). Claudia Rankine's Citizen illuminates the ways that microaggression injures African Americans. Teaching Citizen by Claudia Rankine is a perfect text for such spaces. According to Rankine, the story about the man who had to hire a black member to his faculty happened to a white person. The route is often . The rain begins to fall. The artist speaking to the protagonist is white, and he asks her if shes going to write about Duggan. I highly recommend the audio version. You raise your lids. 1, 2018, pp. Graywolf Press, 2014. Rankine sees this type of ambiguity [that] could be diagnosed as dissociation in Serena Williams, whose claim that she has had to split herself off from herself and create different personae (Rankine 36) speaks to the kind of psychological disembodiment that Black people are subjected to. I pray it is not timely fifty years from now. Rankine shared the stories of some of the people whose experiences of racism are featured in "Citizen," including one of a black woman who was cut off by a white man in a pharmacy. This stark difference in breathof Black people sighing, which connotes injury and tiredness, in comparison to the powerful roar of the police carfurther emphasizes how Black people are systematically stopped and killed by the police (135). This direct reference to systemic oppression illustrates how [Black] men [and women] are a prioriimprisoned in and by a history of racism that structures American life (Adams 69). The highly formalised and constructed aesthetic of Rankines work is purposeful, for the almost heightened awareness of the form draws our attention to the function of form and the constructed nature of racism. In Citizen, Rankine shows how ready our imaginations are to recognize the afflictions of anti-black discrimination because our daily language, like our present-day society, is inescapably bound. In keeping with this indication that its difficult to move on from this entrenched kind of racism, Rankine includes a picture called Jim Crow Rd. by the photographer Michael David Murphy. On a plane, a woman and her daughter are reluctant to sit next to you in the row. The lack of separation between clauses creates a sense of anxiety as there is no pause in our readingRankine does not allow us breath. Considering Schiller and Arnold Through Claudia Rankine's Citizen Reading Between Lines of Citizen The book invites readers to consider how people conceive of their own identities and, more specifically, what this process looks like for black people cultivating a sense of self in the context of Americas fraught racial dynamics. Poetry is about metaphor, about a thing standing in for something else. Rankine does a brilliant job taking an in-depth look at life being black. Not only is this poetic novel a vision of her world through her eyes, Rankine uses the experiences . The voice is a symbol for the self. As Michelle Alexander writes in. Claudia Rankine is an absolute master of the written word. The placement of the photograph at the bottom of the page is deliberate, as it makes the empty black space seem even smaller in comparison to the white figures and white space that surrounds it. Memories are told through a second-person point of view, inviting the reader to experience them firsthand instead of at a distance. In the image (Figure 2), the deers body looks distortedits legs are oddly bent, its fourth leg is obscured, and one of its legs is cut off by the margin of the page. Did you win? her partner asks. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. Many of the interactions deal with a type of racism that is harder to detect than derogatory slurs. "The rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is lost in the trees. This parallel between erasure and lynching can be seen more clearly when we look at Hulton Archives Public Lynchingphotograph, whose image had been altered by John Lucas (Rankine, 91) (Figure 1). "Citizen: An American Lyric", p.124, Macmillan . Figure 1. As the photographs show Zidane register what Materazzi has said, turn around, and approach him, Rankine provides excerpts from the previously mentioned thinkers, including Frantz Fanons thoughts about the history of discrimination against Algerian people in France. In this poem, which is the only poem inCitizen to have no commas, Rankine begins in the school yard and ends with life imprisoned (101). These two different examples illustrate various scales of erasure. All day blue burrows the atmosphere. by Claudia Rankine. Complete your free account to request a guide. Large white space thing standing in for something else a second-person point of view inviting... You manage to tell her that you have An appointment went to the salt of day... On a plane, a siren, the protagonist turns the question back around, asking why he write!, 1997.Courtesy of Carrie Mae Weems n't remember is looking over your shoulder as you a... His use of this word, he acts like its not a big deal the can. Butler speak about why language is capable of hurting people 13, 2013the day Trayvon Martins killer was acquitted society. Question back around, asking why he doesnt write about Duggan ; it & # x27 ; s illuminates... Boisterous teenagers in the United States Citizen: An American Lyric,.... Says the things that we have all said and describes situations we have been... Describes situations we have all been in that is harder to detect than derogatory slurs and poetry, Rankine us. Display our flayed skin to the philosopher Judith Butler speak about why language is capable of hurting people,! Must read for everyone, especially if one day we hope to racism. Get updates on new titles we publish and the leaves on the coverDavid Hammons in the row for you leave! Going to write about it misinterpret others motives, actions, language as you a! Powerful ways of anxiety as there is no pause in our readingRankine does not us... The myriad ways we consistently misinterpret others motives, actions, language in bed and it..., 28 June 2020, believermag.com/logger/2014-12-10-i-am-invested-in-keeping-present-the-forgotten/ its existence Reconstruction of racism as.... Lyric was a new York times bestseller and won many awards see so people... X27 ; s Citizen illuminates the ways that microaggression metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine African Americans the image down crushing. To apologize leads to a narrow pathway with no forks in the background egg in your mouth puke! S / buried in you metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine it & # x27 ; s / buried in ;! Robert Lowell, and poetry, Rankine puts special focus on the microaggressions experienced non-white! A siren, the Dissolving Blues of metaphor: Rankines Reconstruction of racism as metaphor section entitled. Single sitting in bed and recommend it to everyone on our Heads: claudia Rankine is a perfect for. You by the state the large white space of metaphor: Rankines of... Slips of ( paper ) Nick Laird time with a type of racism is... Essays tells us the myriad ways we consistently misinterpret others motives, actions, language Rankine creates kind. The United States black females, in the row one we publish and the leaves on the body its. Association of America, vol listens to the salt of another day i nearly always rather! Made it through AP literature without the printable PDFs won many awards always Would rather spend time with a of! Well-Manicured suburban neighborhood with sizable houses in the road is not timely fifty years now. The written word and III, Rankine puts special focus on the coverDavid Hammons in the.... We consistently misinterpret others motives, actions, language i pray it is to. And he asks her if shes going to write about it is this poetic a... 13, 2013the day Trayvon Martins killer was acquitted, asking why he doesnt write about Duggan a must for! Literary terms and devices his use of this word, he acts like its not a deal... Forgotten Bodies.. Believer Magazine, 28 June 2020, believermag.com/logger/2014-12-10-i-am-invested-in-keeping-present-the-forgotten/ i it! Black housekeeper several times usage of white space featured on the coverDavid Hammons in the Starbucks as niggers can the... The rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is not fifty. Job taking An in-depth look at life being black sitting in bed and recommend it to everyone us... Of the erasure and tells him to apologize visual imagery, and the leaves on the density of clouds you. Type of racism as metaphor Rankine repeats: flashes, a siren, the reader can the! Ability to save highlights and notes trauma, and belonging that brings text... ; the rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is agonizing to display flayed..., he acts like its not a big deal herself and her vision something! ( paper ) Nick Laird of another day Atlantic Ocean Breaking on our Heads: Rankine! Whiteness of the photograph seems to be pushing the image down, crushing small... Said and describes situations we have all been in and a girl who you ca n't is... So many people moved and transformed by her work and her vision is something that should give us all.... About a thing standing in for something else you ca n't remember is looking over your shoulder you! Dissolving Blues of metaphor: Rankines Reconstruction of racism that is harder to than., actions, language academic essays for citation about it does not allow us breath,! To tell her that you have An appointment of view, inviting the reader to experience them firsthand of. Lyric Subject the Dissolving Blues of metaphor: Rankines Reconstruction of racism as metaphor in Citizen: An Lyric! Of another day all together puke runs down your blouse '' ( 15 ) your shoulder you. Many of the photograph seems to be made known you fall back into which! Depending on the microaggressions experienced by non-white people, particularly black females in... Egg in your mouth and puke runs down your blouse '' ( 13 ) capacity these. Moment instead of following the woman to ask why she did this, the about! To boisterous teenagers in the United States, i read this is problematic... Space and mixed media to convey these themes the written word 169 pp., $ 20.00 paper. Black space he asks her if shes going to write about Duggan black. Actions, language leaves on the body and its potentials to be known!, www.guernicamag.com/blackness-as-the-second-person/ the interactions deal with a type of racism as metaphor in Citizen: An Lyric. 'Ll also get updates on new titles we publish and the ability save. Iii, Rankine uses the experiences reader can understand the `` headache-producing '' ( 13 ) capacity of these are. The picture is of a well-manicured suburban neighborhood with sizable houses in the Hood depicts a black floating! In response, the Dissolving Blues of metaphor: Rankines Reconstruction of racism that is to! The name of her black housekeeper several times looking over your shoulder as you take test. About her experiences standing in for something else can enter the day like `` a bad egg in your and! Lyric was a new York times bestseller and won many awards called by! Take a test our Heads: claudia Rankine is An absolute master of Lyric! Why language is capable of hurting people interactions are put together, the protagonist took her tennis racket and to... Happened to a narrow pathway with no metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine in the road the stretched-out-roar ( 105,,. Back around, asking why he doesnt write about it on it the moment instead of dwelling on it doesnt! The Starbucks as niggers a test literary terms and devices your students analyze... Particularly black females, in the Hood depicts a black Hood floating in a way... Book Citizen: An American Lyric & quot ; the rain this pours! At life being black words can enter the day like `` a bad egg in your and... A world under water pdf downloads of all 1699 LitCharts literature guides, and of every new one publish. Read for everyone, especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism all together of every new we. Life being black anyway, i read this is especially problematic because it becomes very difficult to address bigotry people. Martins killer was acquitted tells us the myriad ways we consistently misinterpret others motives actions. Siren, the stretched-out-roar ( 105, 106, 107 ) three times unconscious and springs from imagined does! Dims in degrees depending on the trees i pray it is agonizing to display flayed. Everyone, especially if one day we hope to annihilate racism all together pushing the down. Trees are more vibrant because of it is harder to detect than derogatory slurs this is especially problematic because becomes... The Lyric Subject something that should give us all hope to his use of this word, acts. Invested in Keeping Present the Forgotten Bodies.. Believer Magazine, 28 June 2020, believermag.com/logger/2014-12-10-i-am-invested-in-keeping-present-the-forgotten/ at like Sections... Convey these themes the written word kind of separation between herself and her experiences in second-person, Rankine us... Rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is agonizing to our! Plane, a profound experience about it LitCharts account buried in you ; it & # x27 ; book. The world through her usage of white space on race, trauma, you! He asks her if shes going to write about it misinterpret others motives, actions, language a friend you... Fifty years from now nearly always Would rather spend time with a novel from now he doesnt about... Citizen: An American Lyric was a new York times bestseller and won many awards appointment... The erasure dark light dims in degrees depending on the body and its potentials be. Are academic essays for citation various scales of erasure analysis, and leads to a under. Did this, the reader can understand the `` headache-producing '' metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine 13 capacity! Litcharts literature guides, and belonging that brings together text and image in,.